< See all resources

Transparency, Participation and Accountability in Kazakhstan

An action-research case study of the extractive industry

Two giant oil and gas fields in Kazakhstan that major European oil companies have invested in are high cost projects with few public benefits, a comprehensive new report from Publish What You Pay (PWYP) members and coalitions in three countries has found. Local communities say their health and the local environment have suffered. Public access to information is poor, and the projects have delivered few if any visible economic gains.

Transparency, participation and accountability in Kazakhstan: an action-research case study of the extractive industry, researched and written by Echo and Civil Expertise (PWYP members in Kazakhstan), PCQVP France/Oxfam France and PWYP UK, and co-published with the PWYP Secretariat, focuses on two costly oil and gas projects where European companies have significant stakes: Karachaganak, jointly operated by Royal Dutch Shell (Netherlands/UK) and Eni (Italy); and Kashagan, operated by the North Caspian Operating Company (NCOC) and involving Total (France) as a joint venture partner alongside subsidiaries of Shell, Eni and others.

Based on 18 months’ research, analysis, inquiries to government, and dialogue with companies and citizens, the report concludes that Karachaganak and Kashagan have so far yielded few economic benefits to the country while at times impacting negatively on the environment, local communities and the personal security of industry critics. The report questions the viability of costly oil and gas operations at a time of falling global demand, Covid-19 and the urgent need for an equitable low-carbon energy transition.

Download the executive summary here

Download the full report here.

This report and summary are also available in Russian and French.

Share this content:

Related Resources


Summit for Democracy Country Commitments Proposal

On December 9-10, 2021, the first of two Summits for Democracy  will take place in the United States with the aim of setting forth an affirmative agenda for democratic renewal and to tackle the greatest threats faced by democracies today, including corruption,  through collective action. Corruption in the oil, gas and mineral sector undermines the efforts…

Read Download

Fair Share? Shining a light on the extractive industries fiscal regimes in Mozambique, Tanzania and Uganda

Taxation is seen as one of the most sustainable sources of revenue for governments, with the potential to contribute to investments in basic services and to enhance the social contract between citizens and their government. Our new synthesis research report explores the fiscal regimes in Mozambique, Tanzania and Uganda and how they can be improved…

Read Download

Financing the Military in Myanmar: Analysis of Gas Revenues

Since seizing power in February 2021, the Myanmar military has faced widespread allegations of human rights violations. Companies operating in Myanmar must make challenging decisions about how to responsibly navigate the crisis. International oil companies, including energy majors Total and Chevron, are under particular scrutiny as the military regime continues to sustain itself with revenues…

Read Download