“Water shortages caused by Minas-Rio have reduced local food production. Dust from mine explosions causes respiratory diseases. Fear of tailings dam breach runs high. Rural communities suffer most. There is little evidence of Brazil’s federal, state or local governments managing the mine effectively or getting a fair deal for citizens.” Athayde Motta, Director of IBASE.…Read Download
Brazil: In Search of Transparency
“Water shortages caused by Minas-Rio have reduced local food production. Dust from mine explosions causes respiratory diseases. Fear of tailings dam breach runs high. Rural communities suffer most. There is little evidence of Brazil’s federal, state or local governments managing the mine effectively or getting a fair deal for citizens.” Athayde Motta, Director of IBASE.
A vast iron ore mine in Brazil, owned and operated by UK multinational Anglo American, is causing water shortages, ill-health and disaster anxiety among the local population. Rural, low-income Afro-descendant communities are the most impacted.
Few benefits are visible locally from mining taxes or royalties, and Brazil’s federal, state and local governments seem unable to ensure a fair deal for affected local populations.
Based on a joint research by IBASE and PWYP-UK, the report In Search of Transparency: Ending Opacity in Brazil’s Extractive Sector assesses local costs and benefits, and the environmental and human rights impacts, of Minas-Rio, the world’s ninth largest iron ore mine, located in Minas Gerais State. While the report focuses on a single mine, it also sheds a wider light on problems arising from mineral extraction in Brazil and beyond, including the Brazilian government’s lack of transparency and accountability for mining tax and royalty receipts.
The study highlights key findings and recommendations for the Brazilian federal and subnational governments, Anglo-American, civil society and international financial and multilateral institutions and donors.
A key recommendation is for Brazil to join the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI). Helen Clark, EITI Chair, said that this report “outlines the case for EITI implementation in Brazil – a decision which we would strongly support”.
The report also recommends that Anglo-American undertake a comprehensive human rights impact assessment of the mine, publish and implement a human rights management plan and repeat this every three years. Technical and social alternatives to reduce the wasteful linear model of extraction, production and disposal of solid minerals, with circular closed loops for mineral resourcing, reuse, repurposing and recycling, are also urgently needed.
“Extractive companies worldwide face growing pressure to eradicate environmental and human rights violations in their supply chains and to work with host governments to ensure that benefits of mineral extraction are more fairly shared with affected communities”. Miles Litvinoff, PWYP-UK director and co-author of the report.